“We are human beings!”

No man is an island,
Entire of itself,
Every man is a piece of the continent,
A part of the main.
If a clod be washed away by the sea,
Europe is the less
As well as if a promontory were,
As well as if a manor of thy friend’s
Or of thine own were:
Any man’s death diminishes me,
Because I am involved in mankind,
And therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls;
It tolls for thee.
John Donne

Six degrees of separation: we have all heard of the concept first postulated by the Hungarian writer Frigyes Karinthy (25 June 1887 – 29 August 1938) in his 1929 story Chains. It reminds us that each one of us is linked to everyone else on this planet. We can’t just wash our hands and pretend that we have no connection with the forces of IS or their victims. We are all part of one another’s life, whether settled law-abiding citizens, murdering terrorists or migrants. We cannot, whoever we are, wherever we are, ignore the events in the Middle East and those fleeing from the horrors there. But what can we do? How should we react, how should we respond?

In the last weeks, I have been asked to sign petitions asking the UK government to act in many different ways, ranging from total refusal of assistance – a freeze on foreign aid and a stop to all immigration – to raising the number of asylum seekers accepted, especially Afghan interpreters and Syrians with families.

There are those who are almost paranoid about IS members entering Europe along with the Syrian refugees, and Facebook has shown photos of at least one alleged IS fighter standing on Munich main station. Their knee-jerk reaction is to bring down the portcullis and keep everyone out of these islands. Others are collecting clothes, blankets and toys to take to the “swarms” camped outside Calais as autumn and winter approach. Photos and film footage of their plight abound.

We have also seen photos of the state in which the trains transporting refugees from Hungary to Austria and Germany were left after they had disembarked. For Germanic people, with their love of everything clean and tidy and in the right place, the sight of the filthy, messy compartments and corridors strewn with donated clothes, blankets and toys, comes as a big shock. It’s almost as if the migrants are biting the hand that is feeding them.

The refugees themselves are probably totally unaware of this. It must be utterly confusing for them, especially the children and adolescents, to be beaten, pepper sprayed, water-cannoned, physically and verbally abused in one country and a few hours later to be greeted with applause, food, sweets, good quality clothing (even if it is Bavarian Lederhosen and Trachtenjacke!) and offers of comfortable accommodation.

My heart says that we should support efforts to help these people find a new life. Let’s hope the German and Austrian welcome can endure and extend across the borders into the neighbouring EU countries, and to other continents. Let’s also hope that the migrants will soon understand the expectations of their hosts with regard to behaviour, and that they can learn to adapt to the culture of the countries where they find themselves. And let’s hope that the fears of infiltration by jihadists are unfounded, or that their numbers are small enough to be ineffective.

And not least, as a Christian I believe in loving my neighbour whether my neighbour reciprocates or not. The main point of the story about the Good Samaritan was that the Samaritans were the enemies of the Jews, yet he was the one who showed love in action. I also claim as my motto “Do unto others as you would be done by.” So my heart says help, whatever the circumstances. These are my brothers and sisters.

However, my head has a slightly less impulsive response. I remember the phrase used by the Swiss to refuse asylum to Jews fleeing the Nazis in the Third Reich: Das Boot ist voll! The boat is full, and if we take anyone else on board it will capsize. The metaphor is appropriate in the current context, given that the sea is turning to blood as boat after flimsy boat packed to the brim sinks under its load. Nevertheless, there are cautious voices warning us that this country does not have the capacity to take large numbers of asylum-seekers.

It is a platitude to say that the solution is to tackle the cause and not the symptoms. Much easier said than done, since international law doesn’t allow us to impose our will by force on other countries where we disapprove of their regime. Maybe diplomacy and military action will eventually prevail but in the meantime we still need to alleviate the symptoms. How many people are camped in the Jungle outside Calais, attempting to enter the UK illegally? The fact that some of them are succeeding means that the rest will remain there, and their success encourages more to join them. Can we, should we, continue to block their passage?

David Cameron has proposed to take Syrian refugees only from the camps in the countries neighbouring Syria, refusing any who have undertaken the hazardous journey into Europe. His reasoning is clear: to discourage people from using the so-called services of people-traffickers. But what of the hundreds of thousands who are already in Europe?

Like the UK and Ireland, Denmark can choose whether to participate in the quota scheme. For the moment, it has closed its motorway and suspended rail links with Germany to prevent migrant hordes crossing its borders en route to Sweden, which has offered hospitality. This stand-off will hopefully soon be resolved, and the footsore families re-settled in a more hospitable environment.

The media has snatched up the word ‘migrant’ and it has rapidly been imbued with a pejorative sense. I speak as a migrant myself, having lived and worked in different countries outside the land of my birth for many years. I have, however, always been there legally, abiding by the national laws and, most significantly, paying all my taxes, tithes and contributions to social institutions and insurances. I know from my own experience how important it is to learn the customs and culture of the country where one is resident.

At the moment, after an absence of 4 decades, I have temporarily returned as a stranger to my native land, and find my old familiar environment filled with migrants from many different parts of the world. Although I have spent most of my adult life in an international environment I grew up surrounded by white British faces. Nowadays, I see every possible shade of skin from the palest Poles to the blackest West Africans, including Chinese and other Asians. They all seem to be well integrated here. The majority are working hard, duly paying taxes and other contributions, and providing much-needed services, from waiters and taxi-drivers to nurses and doctors, lawyers and teachers.

Many of those currently making their dangerous way to a new life in Europe are also skilled and well-educated people with much to offer once they are granted asylum. How can we say that we don’t have room for more?

I have also had plenty of contact in my time with refugees and asylum-seekers, a different kind of migrant. Some are genuinely desperate, traumatised people who have been through hell, others – and I would say definitely a minority – are hangers-on with a different agenda. How are the authorities to discriminate between these groups?

Distinctions have also been made in these discussions between so-called “genuine” refugees fleeing persecution and war, and “economic” refugees, who simply “want a better life”. There is a tendency to dismiss the latter, as not really being in want and distress. But consider the huge numbers of Irish who fled to the UK and the USA in the nineteenth century: these were trying to escape starvation and deprivation, too. Yet nobody called them “economic refugees” or denies that they deserved asylum in the countries where they landed. Remember the inscription in the Statue of Liberty? Are those words as hollow as the statue herself?

Others point out that the great majority of refugees at present are from an Islamic background, yet ironically they are fleeing into what used to be called Christendom. In spite of the upheaval in so many countries affected by the Arab Spring, there are still plenty of wealthy, prosperous Arab states that could very easily support large numbers of these people, both financially and in terms of settlement. And they have the advantage of a shared Islamic culture. Is it really so difficult for Sunni and Shia to coexist in peace?

It is never easy to uproot yourself from your native soil and migrate to another country. I know this, even though I migrated from choice. I cannot imagine the heartbreak of having to set out with nothing but what you can carry and, at the mercy of unscrupulous people willing to exploit any kind of human misery, run headlong into the unknown. Of course you hope for a Promised Land and a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. That keeps you going. But how many find it?

The debate goes on. I have no answers.


8 thoughts on ““We are human beings!”

  1. Bravo. You have encapsulated the entire situation here, in fairness and humanity. We too are migrants from choice, and know how much difficulty there is in re-establishing oneself in a new environment, particularly in coping with a new language. What we have always maintained, and tried to live by, is when in Rome, to do as the Romans do.

  2. “Is it really so difficult for Sunni and Shia to coexist in peace?” I think, yes, this is how it is, and often all this is politicised too.
    Your mention the Statue of Liberty. Lind from rangewriter writes about this too; This is a link to her blog:
    Thank you, dear Cat, for this blog. You say exactly how it is. I think the answer lies in standing up for what we believe in. The boat is full. I think on a global level the boat is not too full yet. We just have to learn to share: the earth, the air, water. This belongs not just to a few, but to every human being. Maybe with an enemy like Isis we have to learn to stick together by sharing all our wealth. Only if we learn to overcome our differences and learn to live together in peace instead of creating wars, can such a movement like Isis be defeated. The people who join Isis are desperate people who see no other way to find a place in this world. Our challenge is to defeat Isis by finding a pleasantly humane place for everyone in this world. It should be possible, for at the moment the earth is still rich enough to accommodate everyone. But I realise, that it might take a long time before it sinks in into people that they just have to make room for every desperate person by loving them and treating them humanely.

    • Thank you, dear Uta. Linda has hit the nail on the head, I think. Any religion that becomes rigid, intolerant and unloving is dangerous – from the Spanish Inquisition to jihadi suicide bombers. We can only shine our own little bit of candle-light and warmth, and hope that others will join us.

      • This poem by John Donne, does this sound like a bit of a premonition to you? Is this why you published it in your blog?
        I copied today an article that was published in The Conversation:
        I got the following comment to it:
        “The real agenda right along, as Julian Assange discusses in his recent book, has been to oust President Assad from power. The so-called war against ISIS, is just a pretext to justify western military intervention – given the major funding and support ISIS receives from the CIA, Israel, Turkey and Saudi Arabia. I don’t think the US and their Canadian and Australian friends can succeed in ousting Assad, owing to his strong support from Russia and Iran.”


        Going to the above link I wonder now what is going to happen to Assad and for how long are we going to be involved in destroying ISIS?

        In that article I copied it says:

        “The Syrian civil war is in its fifth year. More than 200,000 civilians have been killed. One-third of the country’s population – seven million people – are internally displaced. Another four million are refugees.”

        I wonder, how does it help, if we are concerned. Yes, we are concerned, still most of us just do not want any disruptions to their lives. We are all in the same boat. and we do not want to rock the boat.

      • Donne didn’t actually write his “Meditation” as a poem, but I find it works better with line breaks. I just came across this article about an Egyptian billionaire who is offering to buy an island from Greece or Italy to resettle refugees http://www.collective-evolution.com/2015/09/10/this-egyptian-billionaire-offers-to-buy-an-island-off-italy-or-greece-to-rehouse-syrian-refugees/ – it would be wonderful if this can really happen.
        Re Assange: I think it’s pretty obvious that the West wants Assad out, it’s certainly no secret. The problem is that IS is not an acceptable alternative, and there doesn’t seem to be any other viable leader available. Some lessons have been learnt from Iraq after getting rid of Saddam Hussein.

  3. I wish all Christians would embrace this: I believe in loving my neighbour whether my neighbour reciprocates or not. You have laid out an eloquent plea for reason and compassion. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s